Vaccine Targets Breast Cancer
By: Elaine Sanchez
(San Antonio, TX) – January 6, 2012 - Military researchers here have
developed a cutting-edge cancer vaccine that’s slashing breast cancer recurrence
rates and giving some survivors a better shot at a cancer-free future.
After more than a decade of research and testing, the cancer vaccine, dubbed
E-75, soon will move on to its final phase of testing to earn Food and Drug
Administration approval, said Army Col. (Dr.) George E. Peoples, director and
principal investigator for the Cancer Vaccine Development Program at San Antonio
Military Medical Center here.
The team has high hopes for this vaccine and its lifesaving potential for breast
cancer survivors, particularly since breast cancer is the most prevalent type of
cancer seen among military beneficiaries in the hospital here, said Peoples, who
also serves as the deputy director of the U.S. Military Cancer Institute and the
medical center’s chief of surgical oncology.
“We’ve made a commitment to take care of active-duty personnel, spouses and
retirees,” the colonel said. “And cancer is a notable problem among
The vaccine, Peoples explained, targets a protein commonly over-expressed in
breast cancer cells called human epidermal growth factor receptor 2, or HER2/neu.
Cancer vaccines typically target some protein or antigen expressed on cancer
cells, he noted. “The idea is to train the immune system to recognize that
protein or piece of protein that’s highly expressed on cancer cells, but not on
normal cells,” he said. “That way the immune system can differentiate what’s
abnormal and normal. If the immune system can recognize it, it marks it for
The cancer vaccine concept has been around for a long time, Peoples noted, but
the team here has adopted a different approach to test their effectiveness. The
vast majority of vaccines in the past were tested on end-stage cancer patients,
he explained. However, a vaccine is meant to stimulate the immune system, and a
healthy immune system isn’t typically seen in someone in the last stages of
As a result, “a lot of early cancer vaccines tested … in end-stage patients were
found not to be helpful,” Peoples said. “No real surprise there.”
To more appropriately gauge the vaccine’s effectiveness, Peoples’ team decided
to test it among patients who have a healthy immune system -- cancer survivors
who are disease-free but at risk for recurrence. Experts can predict recurrence
based on several factors including family history, age, size of tumor and the
presence of involved lymph nodes, among other indicators.
The researchers targeted the HER2/neu protein, which is expressed at varying
levels in women with breast cancer, then honed in on the 60 percent of women who
express the protein at low to intermediate levels. The vaccine is a mix of the
E-75 peptide of the HER2 protein and an immune system stimulant.
They started with a 200-patient trial in 2001 and followed each woman for five
years. Half of the women received the vaccine -- one injection a month for six
months -- and the other half was the control group.
The outcome was very promising, Peoples noted. The recurrence rate among the
women in the control group was 20 percent, and 10 percent among the women who
received the vaccine. “We cut recurrence in half,” he said.
This success led to the next phase of testing, the colonel said, which will
begin early this year and involve 700 to 1,000 patients.
Unlike the earlier phases, however, this step will be undertaken by a commercial
company, Galena Biopharma, which has the resources and manpower to undertake
such a large-scale test. The company will seek FDA approval and, if received,
release the vaccine for public use.
This phase will take about five years to complete -- two years to enroll, then a
three-year observation period, Peoples said.
“The end point is the recurrence rate after three years,” he explained.
Meanwhile, Peoples and his team will turn their attention to a multitude of
other projects, many based on the same concept that made the E-75 vaccine so
successful -- using the body’s own immune system to destroy cancer cells.
They’ve already taken the same vaccine and completed a trial with prostate
cancer survivors. As with ovarian and lung cancer, prostate cancer also
expresses the HER2 protein.
Peoples said he’s also intrigued by a successful trial they conducted on breast
cancer survivors who express the HER2 protein at the highest levels, rather than
the low to intermediate levels they focused on before. In this study, they
combined their vaccine with the drug Herceptin.
They conducted a small trial with 60 women, Peoples said, and when they
administered the vaccine and Herceptin together, the recurrence rate dropped to
zero. “The preliminary data is very exciting,” he said. “But we need to wait and
do larger trials.”
Word has spread of the cancer vaccine program’s successes and intriguing
results. Military and civilian experts have approached Peoples wanting to take
part in research that has such a potentially widespread impact. The idea of
active, specific immunotherapy -- engaging the body’s immune system to do the
work of fighting the cancer -- is an exciting and rapidly evolving area, Peoples
Garnering this interest, Peoples has steadily built a worldwide network of
military and civilian hospitals that can assist with clinical trials and
research. The network includes just about every major military hospital
alongside a civilian hospital in cities across the nation and overseas.
The partnership has reached Athens, Greece, and is about to extend into
Malaysia. “We’re about to circle the globe,” he said.
Peoples attributed much of the program’s successes to this military-civilian
network. “We’re very fortunate to have great partners,” he said.
He also praised the military men and women willing to take part in the trials.
They enter into them knowing they may be part of the control group that doesn’t
receive a potentially lifesaving vaccine. Despite that fact, he hasn’t seen a
shortage of willing participants, Peoples said.
“The military is an ideal setting for clinical trials,” he said.
Service members, retirees and family members have a strong sense of service, he
noted. “They want to be involved and contribute to the research,” he added.
While they’re focusing on secondary cancer prevention, the ultimate goal,
Peoples noted, is primary prevention, meaning cancer prevention among people
with a predicted risk of cancer based on family history and genetic markers.
“Hopefully, sometime in my lifetime we’ll figure that out,” he said.